So the other day I got this email that Google was dead, move all your advertising to Facebook.
The arguments, as they were made, were as follows:
1. Google is too big and expensive
2. Facebook is nicer and costs less.
(THOSE ARGUMENTS WILL ALWAYS MAKE SENSE HERE IN THE PHILIPPINES WHERE YOU GOTTA BE NICE AND ALL. REALLY. JUST LOOK AT OUR ELECTIONS.)
3. Facebook doesn’t charge per click, it charges per placement, the same as Yahoo and Bing. Unlike Yahoo and Bing, people stay ON Facebook, all day, so theoretically, your ad is in front of your target market while they’re throwing cows, dishing out meals from a diner, taking care of abandoned farm animals and whatever else they do on Facebook on company time. Not a bad deal for your placement.
4. Add the function of being able to target specific groups, individuals, causes, schools, political beliefs, and create fan pages where people click “likes this” to signify how well your product is doing. Well and good.
Yesterday, I got another email, this time, pro-Google. Again, the arguments also made sense:
1. Google still has more unique visitors per day than Facebook. Facebook’s numbers are all the same people.
2. Facebook still hasn’t figured out what to do with their data in a way that will help you allocate your spending. (I dunno about that, I saw an article about it, there were too many zeros in the figures mentioned that my brain just froze.)
3. When people are about to buy something, and haven’t quite made up their minds on what to buy, they hit Google Search. When people are actively seeking information about a particular product, service or whatever else they are about to spend their money on, they go to Google.
(Makes sense. The only time I’ve seen someone go on Facebook to decide what to buy was when it was a really expensive item that the person had already decided on, and was seeking peer approval in order to rationalize the horrifical unnecessary expense…never mind, I got set off.)
4. You can target people on Google. In fact, you can target them more effectively if your media person knows what he’s doing. It’s called Pay-Per-Click, and the keyword analysis tool is free.
So. Google or Facebook?
The mindset of a person who will be seeing your ad on Google is different from a persom
Advertising-wise, if your product isn’t already on the mind of the customer on the verge of buying, your chance of changing his or her mind with an online ad is much higher in Google than it would be on Facebook. Facebook is a television ad. Google Search is a salesperson racing towards a person holding a product in the category yours is in (and might even be yours) and telling the prospective buyer about what options there are while steering him/her in the category shelf AND THEN positioning your prospective buyer right smack in the middle of where yours is in, while giving him/her your pitch.
Going by the Prodigy Perspectives matrix, Facebook straddles the line between the PREPARE/PROMOTE grids while Google Search lands squarely in the middle of the PUSH grid.
So there you go: both are equally effective for different objectives and stages of your marketing communications plan.
For more about Prodigy Perspectives and communications that work, email us at info@prodigyads.com.
UP NEXT: Google (Search) Is My Friend, How To Use Facebook for Best Results.
Both are equally effective, depending on your objectives